Digital Gym is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more
Home › Comparisons › Concept2 vs Hydrow vs Ergatta
Concept2 vs Hydrow vs Ergatta: Which Rowing Machine Is Best in 2026?
Last updated: March 2026
Rowing machines are having a moment, and for good reason. They deliver a full-body, low-impact workout that burns serious calories while building strength from your legs to your core to your back. But the rowing machine market has split into two distinct camps: the no-frills workhorse (Concept2) versus the connected-fitness experience (Hydrow and Ergatta).
We have spent hundreds of hours researching, comparing specs, and analyzing real-world user feedback on all three machines. This guide breaks down everything you need to know — resistance feel, build quality, noise levels, content, and the real cost of ownership over three years — so you can figure out which one actually deserves space in your home.
Let’s get into it.
Concept2 vs Hydrow vs Ergatta: Full Spec Comparison
Before we dive into the nuances, here’s a side-by-side look at the hard numbers. These are the specs that matter most when choosing a rowing machine.
| Spec | Concept2 RowErg | Hydrow | Ergatta Luxe |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $990 | $1,995 | $2,299 |
| Subscription | None required ($0/mo) | $44/mo (required for content) | $29/mo (recommended, not required) |
| Resistance Type | Air (flywheel) | Electromagnetic | Water |
| Display | PM5 monitor (backlit LCD) + phone holder | 22” Full HD touchscreen | 17.3” HD touchscreen |
| Dimensions (L x W) | 96” x 24” | 86” x 25” | 86” x 23” |
| Machine Weight | 57 lbs | 145 lbs | ~107 lbs (with water) |
| Max User Weight | 500 lbs | 375 lbs | 500 lbs |
| Storage | Separates into 2 pieces; foldable | Upright storage (kit sold separately) | Upright storage (built-in tilt) |
| Connectivity | Bluetooth, ANT+ | Wi-Fi, Bluetooth | Wi-Fi, Bluetooth |
| Content Library | None built-in (works with ErgData, Peloton app, Asensei, etc.) | 4,000+ workouts (rowing, yoga, pilates, strength) | Game-based workouts, races, challenges, interval programs |
| Frame Material | Aluminum and steel | Aluminum and steel | Cherry wood (handcrafted) |
| Max User Height | 6’6” | 6’5” | 6’8” |
| Warranty | 5 years frame, 2 years parts | 5 years frame, 1 year parts | 5 years frame and parts |
Resistance Type & Feel
This is the single biggest difference between these three machines, and it affects everything — how the stroke feels, how loud it is, and whether you will enjoy rowing on it every day.
Concept2 RowErg: Air Resistance
The Concept2 uses a flywheel with a damper lever that controls airflow. The harder you pull, the more resistance you get. It’s a completely natural, self-adjusting system — there is no motor, no electronics controlling the load. The feel is smooth and responsive, with a satisfying “whoosh” on every stroke.
The damper setting (1–10) controls how much air enters the flywheel. A common misconception is that higher damper equals harder. In reality, it changes the feel of the stroke: lower damper feels like rowing a sleek racing shell, higher damper feels like rowing a heavy barge. Most experienced rowers keep it between 3 and 5.
The downside? Air resistance is the loudest of the three types. At moderate intensity, the Concept2 generates roughly 70–80 dB — comparable to a loud conversation or a dishwasher running. Sprint intervals push it higher.
Hydrow: Electromagnetic Resistance
The Hydrow uses computer-controlled electromagnetic resistance, which means the machine adjusts resistance electronically. This allows for precisely calibrated difficulty levels and seamless integration with the on-screen workouts — an instructor can tell the software to increase your resistance automatically.
The feel is smooth and consistent, though some rowing purists note it lacks the natural, variable response of air or water resistance. The catch (the initial pull) feels slightly different than what you would experience on actual water. That said, for most home rowers, the difference is subtle and the overall experience is excellent.
The biggest advantage: electromagnetic resistance is nearly silent. You will mostly hear the seat gliding on the rail, which is barely audible.
Ergatta: Water Resistance
The Ergatta uses a water tank with internal paddles. When you pull the handle, the paddles spin through water, creating resistance. Like air resistance, it scales naturally with effort — pull harder, get more resistance.
The feel is widely considered the closest to actual on-water rowing. The initial catch has a heavier, more connected feel, and the resistance builds smoothly through the stroke. Many rowers describe the sensation as more “organic” than either air or magnetic.
Noise-wise, the Ergatta falls in the middle. The swooshing sound of water is noticeably quieter than the Concept2’s air flywheel but louder than the Hydrow’s near-silent magnetic system. Many users actually prefer the water sound — it adds an almost meditative quality to the workout.
Bottom line: If authentic rowing feel is your priority, the Ergatta’s water resistance is the closest to on-water rowing. The Concept2’s air resistance is the competitive standard. The Hydrow’s electromagnetic system is the smoothest and quietest, but the least “natural” feeling of the three.
Build Quality & Storage
Concept2 RowErg
The Concept2 is legendarily durable. These machines are used in Olympic training centers, CrossFit boxes, and college boathouses — environments where they take an absolute beating day after day. The aluminum I-beam monorail and steel frame are built to last decades, not years. With basic maintenance (occasionally wiping the rail and oiling the chain), a Concept2 will outlast pretty much anything else in your home gym.
For storage, the RowErg separates into two pieces (the monorail lifts off the flywheel unit) in about 10 seconds without any tools. Separated, it stores in a footprint of about 25” x 33” x 54”. At just 57 lbs, it is easily the lightest and most portable of the three machines.
Hydrow
The Hydrow has a premium feel with its sleek, low-profile design. The aluminum and steel frame is solid, though at 145 lbs it is a substantial piece of equipment. Build quality is good, but it does not have the industrial-grade durability of the Concept2 — it is designed for home use, not a commercial gym.
Storage is the Hydrow’s biggest challenge. It does not fold or separate. You can store it upright against a wall using an Upright Storage Kit (sold separately for around $80), which gives it a footprint of about 25” x 33”. But at 145 lbs, tipping it upright is not exactly effortless. The 22” touchscreen also makes you nervous every time you move it.
The weight capacity of 375 lbs is the lowest of the three, which is worth noting for larger users.
Ergatta Luxe
The Ergatta is a genuinely beautiful machine. It is built on a WaterRower frame using handcrafted American cherry wood, and it looks more like a piece of furniture than exercise equipment. If aesthetics matter to you (and for a machine that lives in your living room, they might), the Ergatta wins this category hands down.
It stores upright with a built-in tilt mechanism — no separate kit needed. Standing up, it takes up roughly 23” x 23” of floor space, which is excellent. At about 107 lbs with water, it is heavier than the Concept2 but lighter than the Hydrow.
The 500 lb weight capacity matches the Concept2, and the 5-year warranty covers both the frame and parts — the best warranty of the three.
Bottom line: The Concept2 is the most durable and easiest to store. The Ergatta is the most attractive and stores well upright. The Hydrow is the heaviest and trickiest to store, but looks sleek and modern in any room.
Content & Training Experience
This is where the three machines diverge the most dramatically. It’s also where personal preference matters more than any spec sheet.
Concept2 RowErg: The Open Platform
The Concept2 has no built-in content. Its PM5 monitor displays your pace, distance, calories, watts, and stroke rate — everything a serious rower needs, nothing they don’t. Think of it as the “bring your own entertainment” approach.
But here is the thing most people overlook: the Concept2’s open ecosystem is actually a massive strength. The PM5’s Bluetooth and ANT+ connectivity lets you pair with a huge range of apps:
- ErgData (free) — Concept2’s own app. Tracks every workout, syncs to your online logbook, and lets you race other users.
- Peloton App ($12.99/mo) — Guided rowing classes with Peloton instructors. A fraction of the Hydrow subscription cost.
- Asensei — AI-powered form coaching using your phone’s camera.
- Strava, Apple Health, Google Fit — Seamless data sync.
- ErgRace, RowAlong — Community racing and virtual rowing.
You can prop a tablet or phone on the built-in device holder and have a connected experience for a fraction of what Hydrow or Ergatta charge. You just have to set it up yourself.
Hydrow: The Peloton of Rowing
If you have ever used a Peloton bike, the Hydrow experience will feel familiar. The 22” Full HD touchscreen is gorgeous, and the content library includes over 4,000 workouts: live rows, on-demand sessions, scenic rows, and off-the-rower content like yoga, pilates, strength, and stretching.
The workouts are filmed on actual water — rivers, lakes, and harbors around the world — which is a genuinely immersive touch. Instructors are engaging and the production quality is top-tier. For people who thrive on instructor-led classes and need external motivation to stay consistent, the Hydrow experience is the best in the rowing market.
The downside is cost: $44/month ($528/year) is steep, and the machine becomes a very expensive towel rack without it. You can use the Hydrow without a subscription for basic “Just Row” mode, but you lose access to all the content that justifies the premium hardware price.
Ergatta: The Gamified Approach
Ergatta takes a completely different approach. There are no instructors, no classes, and no one talking at you. Instead, the 17.3” touchscreen presents data-driven games, races, and challenges that are personalized to your fitness level.
You might race a ghost of your personal best, compete in a community challenge, navigate a course that requires interval pacing, or just try to beat your previous distance in a set time. The entire experience is calibrated to your own performance data, so workouts automatically scale as you get fitter.
This approach works brilliantly for people who are competitive, enjoy video games, or simply find instructor-led classes annoying. It is also great for people who prefer to listen to their own music or podcasts while rowing — the games are visual, so you don’t need audio from the screen.
At $29/month ($348/year), the subscription is cheaper than Hydrow’s. You can use the Ergatta without a subscription and it functions as a standard water rower, but you lose the game-based experience.
Bottom line: If you want total control and hate paying subscriptions, the Concept2 wins by a mile. If you need a coach and love classes, Hydrow is best-in-class. If you want to gamify your fitness without someone telling you what to do, Ergatta is the most fun you will have on a rower.
Noise Levels
If you live in an apartment, share walls with neighbors, or row while others are sleeping, noise level is a legitimate factor. Here’s how the three compare:
- Hydrow: Quietest. Electromagnetic resistance produces almost no sound. You will hear the seat rolling on the rail and your own breathing. That’s about it. Estimated 50–60 dB at normal pace.
- Ergatta: Moderate. The water swoosh is pleasant and rhythmic, but audible in the same room. Think of it as a calming white-noise effect. Estimated 55–65 dB at normal pace.
- Concept2: Loudest. The air flywheel generates a clear “whoosh” that increases with intensity. At moderate pace, expect 70–80 dB. During hard intervals, it climbs higher. Not ideal for thin-walled apartments or early-morning sessions.
For context: 60 dB is a normal conversation, 70 dB is a running shower, and 80 dB is a garbage disposal. The Concept2 is not unreasonably loud, but it is noticeably louder than the other two, especially during intense efforts.
Bottom line: If noise is a dealbreaker, the Hydrow is the clear winner. The Ergatta is a good middle ground. The Concept2 is perfectly fine in a garage, basement, or well-insulated room, but think twice if you share walls.
Price & Total Cost of Ownership
The sticker price only tells half the story. Subscription costs add up fast, and the true cost of a connected rower is dramatically higher than it appears at checkout. Let’s do the math over three years.
| Cost Breakdown | Concept2 RowErg | Hydrow | Ergatta Luxe |
|---|---|---|---|
| Machine Price | $990 | $1,995 | $2,299 |
| Monthly Subscription | $0 | $44/mo | $29/mo |
| Year 1 Total | $990 | $2,523 | $2,647 |
| Year 2 Total | $990 | $3,051 | $2,995 |
| Year 3 Total | $990 | $3,579 | $3,343 |
| Cost Difference vs Concept2 | — | +$2,589 more | +$2,353 more |
Read those numbers again. Over three years, the Hydrow costs $3,579 — that is $2,589 more than the Concept2. The Ergatta comes in at $3,343 — $2,353 more than the Concept2.
And the Concept2 will likely last you 10–15+ years with minimal maintenance. If you amortize that $990 over a decade of daily use, you are paying about 27 cents per day to row. That is borderline insane value.
Now, to be fair: if the Hydrow or Ergatta subscription keeps you rowing consistently when you otherwise would not, that subscription cost delivers real value. A $3,500 machine you actually use five days a week is a better investment than a $990 machine collecting dust in the corner. Only you can honestly assess which camp you fall into.
Also worth noting: if you ever cancel your Hydrow subscription, you lose access to all content and are left with a basic rowing machine that costs twice what a Concept2 does. The Ergatta at least functions as a solid standalone water rower without its subscription.
Who Should Buy Which
Buy the Concept2 RowErg if you…
- Are self-motivated and don’t need an instructor to push you
- Want the best long-term value with zero ongoing costs
- Train for CrossFit, competitive rowing, or just want the industry standard
- Prefer an open ecosystem and want to choose your own apps and content
- Need a machine that will survive anything you throw at it for 10+ years
- Are a larger user (the 500 lb capacity is unmatched at this price)
- Want something easy to store and move around
Buy the Hydrow if you…
- Need instructor-led classes to stay motivated and consistent
- Love the Peloton-style connected fitness experience
- Want a whisper-quiet machine for apartment living
- Value a beautiful, immersive screen experience
- Want off-the-rower content (yoga, pilates, strength) bundled in
- Don’t mind paying $44/month for a premium content library
Buy the Ergatta Luxe if you…
- Want the most realistic water-rowing feel at home
- Are competitive and love gamified, data-driven challenges
- Find instructors and classes annoying or patronizing
- Want a machine that doubles as a living-room centerpiece
- Prefer to listen to your own music/podcasts while rowing
- Want a quieter alternative to the Concept2 with more built-in tech
Pros & Cons
Concept2 RowErg
- Best value in the entire rowing machine market ($990, no subscription)
- Legendary durability — built for commercial gym abuse
- Air resistance scales naturally with effort for an authentic feel
- PM5 monitor tracks every metric that matters
- Open ecosystem: Bluetooth/ANT+ works with dozens of apps
- Lightest of the three (57 lbs) and easy to fold for storage
- 500 lb weight capacity
- Massive global community for online racing and benchmarks
- 10–15+ year lifespan with minimal maintenance
- Loudest of the three — not ideal for apartments or shared spaces
- No built-in screen or content — need to bring your own device
- PM5 monitor looks dated compared to touchscreen competitors
- No guided coaching for beginners out of the box
- Industrial look won’t win any interior design awards
- Longer footprint (96”) than Hydrow or Ergatta
Hydrow
- Stunning 22” HD touchscreen with immersive on-water visuals
- 4,000+ workouts with world-class instructors
- Whisper-quiet electromagnetic resistance — best for apartments
- Includes off-rower content (yoga, pilates, strength, stretching)
- Sleek, modern design that looks great in any room
- Live and on-demand classes keep workouts fresh
- Computer-controlled resistance adjusts to workout programs
- Expensive: $1,995 machine + $44/mo subscription ($3,579 over 3 years)
- Heaviest of the three (145 lbs) — difficult to move
- 375 lb weight capacity is the lowest of the three
- Basically useless without the subscription
- Electromagnetic feel lacks the natural response of air or water
- Upright storage kit sold separately
- Closed ecosystem — locked into Hydrow content
Ergatta Luxe
- Beautiful handcrafted cherry wood design — furniture-grade aesthetics
- Water resistance provides the most realistic on-water feel
- Game-based workouts are genuinely addictive and fun
- Workouts auto-calibrate to your fitness level
- Quieter than Concept2, with a pleasant water swoosh sound
- 500 lb weight capacity
- Built-in upright storage (no extra kit needed)
- Best warranty of the three (5 years frame and parts)
- Lower subscription cost than Hydrow ($29/mo vs $44/mo)
- Most expensive upfront ($2,299)
- No instructor-led classes or guided workouts
- 17.3” screen is smaller than Hydrow’s 22”
- Water tank requires occasional treatment to prevent algae
- Game-based approach is not for everyone — some people want structure
- No off-the-rower content (rowing only)
- Smaller content library compared to Hydrow
Final Verdict
After looking at every angle — resistance feel, build quality, content, noise, and especially total cost of ownership — here is where we land.
The Concept2 RowErg is the no-brainer value pick and our overall top recommendation. At $990 with no subscription, it delivers a world-class rowing experience that will last a decade or more. It is the machine used by Olympic athletes, CrossFit competitors, and college rowing teams. You can pair it with free apps like ErgData or pay $12.99/month for Peloton rowing classes and still spend less in 10 years than a Hydrow costs in 3. Unless you specifically need the features of a connected rower, the Concept2 is the smartest purchase.
The Hydrow is for people who know themselves well enough to admit they need motivation. If you are the kind of person who buys gym equipment and stops using it after a month, the Hydrow’s instructor-led classes and community features are genuinely valuable. The content is excellent, the screen is beautiful, and the machine is whisper-quiet. You are paying a premium for accountability, and if that keeps you rowing 4–5 times a week, it is money well spent. Just go in with eyes open about the $3,579 three-year cost.
The Ergatta Luxe is the fun pick. If you love competition, enjoy games, and want a rowing machine that looks like a piece of art in your living room, the Ergatta delivers an experience that nothing else in this market matches. The water resistance feels incredible, the gamified workouts are addictive, and the cherry wood design is legitimately stunning. It is the most expensive option upfront, but the lower subscription cost makes it cheaper than the Hydrow over time.
No matter which you choose, you are getting an excellent piece of equipment. Rowing is one of the best full-body, low-impact workouts you can do, and all three of these machines will serve you well. The question is just which experience matches how you like to train — and how much you want to spend getting there.
Frequently Asked Questions
Absolutely. The Concept2 RowErg remains the gold standard for rowing machines in 2026. At $990 with no subscription required, it offers the best long-term value of any rower on the market. It uses air resistance that scales naturally with your effort, has a 500 lb weight capacity, and the PM5 monitor connects to dozens of third-party apps including ErgData, Peloton, and Strava. Every Olympic rowing team and CrossFit gym still uses the Concept2 for a reason — it is virtually indestructible and delivers an authentic rowing feel that no connected rower has matched.
It depends on what motivates you. The Hydrow subscription ($44/month) gives you access to 4,000+ instructor-led workouts filmed on real water, plus off-the-rower content like yoga, pilates, and strength training. If you are the type of person who needs a coach in your ear and a structured class to stay consistent, the Hydrow subscription is genuinely excellent and worth the cost. If you are self-motivated and just want to row, you will get more value from a Concept2 with free apps.
The Hydrow is quieter. Its electromagnetic resistance system produces very little noise — mostly just the sound of the seat rolling on the rail. The Ergatta uses water resistance, which creates a pleasant swooshing sound as you row. While the water sound is not loud (and many people find it soothing), the Hydrow is objectively the quieter machine and the better choice for apartment living or rowing while others sleep.
Yes. The Concept2 RowErg’s PM5 monitor supports Bluetooth and ANT+ connectivity, making it compatible with a wide range of third-party apps. ErgData (Concept2’s free companion app) tracks all your workouts and syncs to your online logbook. You can also connect to the Peloton app ($12.99/month) for guided rowing classes, plus apps like Asensei, RowAlong, and Strava. This open ecosystem is one of the Concept2’s biggest strengths — you are never locked into a single content provider.
For absolute beginners, the Hydrow offers the most guided experience with instructor-led classes that teach proper form and gradually build intensity. The Ergatta is also beginner-friendly thanks to its game-based approach that makes workouts feel less intimidating and automatically calibrates to your fitness level. The Concept2 is a fantastic machine but offers no built-in coaching — beginners will need to use external apps or YouTube tutorials to learn proper rowing technique. If budget is a concern, the Concept2 with the free ErgData app and some YouTube form tutorials is the smartest starting point.
Related Articles
Best Rowing Machines in 2026
Our complete ranking of the best rowing machines at every price point, from budget picks to premium connected rowers.
Tonal vs Tempo vs Speediance
Three smart home gyms, three different approaches. Here’s which one is actually worth your money.
Best Home Gym Under $2,000
The sweet spot for most people. At this budget, you can build a genuinely great training setup at home.